Photoshop Magic Challenge
Rikard Rodin

Photoshop Magic Challenge

May 2019

Crowd and
Expert winner

A great composite that captures the spirit of the competition! The color scheme is works and the whimsical placement of elements serves the composite well. In the spirit of always improving, the two issues I see for future improvement: 1) The background buildings are not necessary and removing them would put more focus on the subject of your image, 2) The clouds look "rendered" which detracts from the composite. Either use more realistic clouds or simply leave the sky blue. Often with a composite, the last step is to "kill your darlings"—get rid of the things that aren't contributing to the image. But overall, really well done!

792 Images entered

544 Photographers

Awesome color scheme! And the compositing work is excellent. Where it falters for me is that it lacks any focal point and so I lose interest rather quickly. The light ring on the right seems to break the pattern, but doesn't otherwise have much relevance. A single "version" of the woman looking at the life ring might have done the trick. Or one of her looking at camera. But as a composite—excellent work!

Meet the expert judge

34,084 Ratings

A clever and simple idea! To improve it, I recommend some vignetting and also giving the image a color grade. Also some atmospheric depth would give the whole thing a lot more scale—helping to sell the "huge plug" concept more.

Entry 3803807
11th
150
Entry 3810866
116th
45
Entry 3814435
20th
139
Entry 3878068
694th
2

Crop, crop, crop. The compositing work is really good! But you have a lot of background "nothing" that isn't contributing to your image. I'd suggest either replacing the background with something more interesting, or cropping closer and adding some blur to the background and some vignette to the foreground. Love the animal!

Entry 3920116
16th
18
Entry 3936900
282nd
73
Entry 3938685
418th
19
Entry 3940837
251st
342
Entry 3947954
18th
19
Entry 3955966
138th
7
Entry 3966673
601st
83
Entry 3988540
79th
16

Great image! Love the grain and color grade. One place to improve is the dark edges around some of the hands. This is a nitpick but is one of those fine details that if fixed, will make your whole composite look a lot more professional.

Brief

See more contest details

Photoshop (and other image editing software) has allowed us to create images that are impossible to capture in camera. From the beautiful to the bizarre, composites created from our own photos allow us to unleash our imagination and creativity! From a portrait of Lincoln composited in the 1860s to the Cottingley Fairy photos of 1917, photo manipulation has existed for as long as photographs have. And in February of 1990, when Adobe released the first version of Photoshop, compositing images became available to any photographer with a computer. Fast forward to today, and you will be hard pressed to find any photo in the media that hasn’t been manipulated or composited in some way. We want to see your imagination unleashed. The rules are simple: at least two different photos, solely taken by yourself, must have been used to create your composite. Give us your twisted, dark, bizarre, beautiful and whimsical! We want composites that would be impossible to capture in camera.

Entry 3794075
37th
15
Entry 3794481
15th
127

All the elements are there for a great composition, but it breaks down in the execution. Matching the lighting (including shadows) and giving the whole thing a color grade would have gone a long way in improving this composite. But you definitely have an eye for compositing so keep learning!

Entry 3803814
27th
124
Entry 3860863
43rd
50
Entry 3872914
25th
73
Entry 3927380
497th
5
Entry 3930403
692nd
6
Entry 3983462
314th
174

You've got a good eye for compositing but need to improve on your technique. Be careful of the "dark halo" that comes from a selection that's not tight enough. Also, matching your black point is important. Keep practicing. You're on the verge of greatness!

Entry 4006918
33rd
5